6 Key Tips for Choosing the Best Type of Porch Columns

Choosing the right material for porch posts can feel overwhelming. Fiberglass, concrete, steel, and wood each have distinct strengths and weaknesses. This means each is suitable for specific conditions and needs.

In this blog, we’ll help you find the best type of porch columns that can perfectly address your needs. We’ll examine various materials and their characteristics, and share practical tips to guide your decision.

The Importance of Choosing the Best Type of Porch Columns

There are two types of porch posts: structural and decorative. Regardless of the column’s responsibility, you must choose the material carefully to extend its lifespan, ensure its stability under heavy loads, and bring beauty to your entrance.

First, the chosen material must be able to withstand the weight being pushed onto the load-bearing columns, transferring it to the base effectively. Comparing fiberglass columns vs wood, concrete, and steel columns reveals that each has its unique strengths and weaknesses. If you choose the wrong material for your porch columns, you’ll face costly issues later, often requiring repair or complete porch column replacement.

Regarding aesthetics, porch design plays a strong role in influencing the first impression visitors have. Poorly designed porch columns can negatively impact guests’ perception, even if other parts of your home are decorated to the highest standards.

In addition to the structure’s safety and aesthetics, the material used for the porch columns directly impacts the curb appeal of the house and the ongoing maintenance costs. Another important factor for choosing the best type of porch columns is the need to comply with building codes, consider the area’s weather conditions, and take durability into account.

In general, a column’s material is important because it’s expected to:

• Guarantee safety and lasting support
• Enhance the home’s appearance
• Reduce costs and troubles over time
• Increase the property’s market value

Different Types of Porch Columns by Material

When choosing the best type of porch columns, these four materials are your primary options:

Fiberglass Columns

Made by combining glass fibers and resin, fiberglass columns are both lightweight and strong. This type of material is fully resistant to decay and requires minimal maintenance. Choosing fiberglass column replacement ensures long-lasting durability and lower maintenance needs.

Additionally, fiberglass columns can be manufactured in various shapes and designs, enabling homeowners to enhance their home’s exterior with a style that complements the overall design.

Despite all these advantages, even fiberglass is not free of weaknesses. Our engineers say that installation requires precision, as even small mistakes can compromise performance. Moreover, a proper connection is critical to ensure that this material can deliver all the expected advantages.

While inherently more durable and resistant to many environmental factors, fiberglass still needs UV-resistant painting to ensure its stability. This adds to the initial costs, which are usually high and considered one of the cons of this type of column.

Concrete Columns

As expected, concrete can bear extreme loads with ease, making it one of the best choices for structural porch columns. It resists many environmentally destructive elements and won’t be affected by rot, pests, humidity, or decay. As a result, it requires relatively little upkeep and is less expensive to maintain.

Shaping and designing concrete in various styles is feasible. Therefore, you can easily match it with the overall look of the house.

On the downside, one key drawback is the significant weight of concrete columns, which can make the installation process technically demanding. Due to its weight, a proper foundation is also necessary to support the column and distribute the load effectively, ensuring the column performs optimally.

Although resistant to rot, humidity, and decay, this type of material is prone to cracks and shrinkage. Additionally, Concrete columns tend to be an expensive solution for porch posts, as their installation and addition of decorative details can also be costly.

As mentioned earlier, concrete can be formed in different shapes. However, the problem is that once the concrete is poured and set, making any adjustments would be very difficult and sometimes impossible. Similarly, repairing a damaged finish in a way that exactly replicates the original design is a complex task.

Steel Columns

Steel has an excellent strength-to-weight ratio. This means that steel columns can support significant loads despite their relatively small size. In simpler terms, homeowners can leverage slimmer posts and take up less space while supporting similar loads to those that a large concrete column can carry.

Unlike concrete and fiberglass, installing steel columns is relatively easier. These columns are usually prefabricated and transferred to the site, where they are bolted or welded by experienced workers. However, similar to other materials, skilled contractors must install these columns on-site to ensure proper connections, which are crucial for optimal performance.

Steel offers both durability, due to its resistance to rot and pests, and also provides aesthetic value. It doesn’t warp, twist, or shrink, and can also be manufactured in industrial or modern styles.

Regarding its disadvantages, it is worth noting that this type of material is susceptible to rust and corrosion due to exposure to humidity. This means proper coating and regular maintenance are necessary to extend its longevity.

Furthermore, steel can get damaged by extreme heat and cold, as it’s thermally conductive. Simply put, being exposed to severe heat or cold can cause the column to expand or contract, risking the structural integrity of both the column and the building.

Although perfectly suitable for modern houses with minimalist design, steel often contradicts traditional houses, where materials like cedar wood better complement the appearance. It can be clad or dressed to fit the design, but this also increases the initial installation costs of these types of columns, which are relatively expensive.

Wood Columns

Whether made from solid timber, such as cedar, oak, or pine, or engineered wood, like glulam or laminated, wood is one of the most popular porch column materials used widely across Canada, especially for historical homes.

It’s one of the least resistant materials for porch posts, prone to decay, rot, pests, and moisture. Nevertheless, many homeowners still consider it the best type of porch columns due to its natural beauty and warmth, lower initial costs, availability, ease of installation, customizability, and thermal insulation.

Nevertheless, you should be aware of all challenges related to this type of material before finalizing your choice of porch column material.

Harsh weather can seriously damage wood columns. They’re prone to various environmental elements, including pests and dampness, due to their exposure to humidity. To extend the lifespan and durability of the wood surface, painting it with rot-resistant paint is mandatory. In addition to these, this material requires regular inspection and upkeep to detect column replacement signs early, before they develop into serious structural problems.

No matter how well you maintain wood columns, their lifespan is significantly shorter compared with steel, concrete, and fiberglass columns.

6 Tips for Choosing the Best Material for Porch Columns

Take these six tips into consideration to ensure you’re making the right decision:

• Consider climate and weather conditions: The best type of porch columns should effectively withstand environmental elements and not be damaged by the local climate.
• Evaluate maintenance complexity: Beyond initial costs, consider the long-term maintenance efforts required for a specific type of material.
• Balance costs with lifespan and value: While expenses play a crucial role in deciding on the type of porch post, cost shouldn’t be your only priority. Cheaper options typically incur higher maintenance costs over time, ultimately negating your initial savings.
• Choose the material that suits your home’s style: While not the top priority, aligning the column’s material with your home’s design should play a significant role in your decision.
• Check building codes in your area: Ensure the type you choose complies with local building codes and won’t cause you any legal issues later.
• Consider load capacity and foundation requirements: Heavier columns that can carry higher weights need stronger foundations, which should be prepared before installation.

Best Type of Porch Columns for Different Needs

Your unique requirements determine the best solution. Therefore, you should assess every aspect and decide on the most suitable material for your porch posts. However, we can offer some hints to help you choose the best type of porch columns.

If you’re looking for an option that is durable and highly resistant to damaging environmental factors, fiberglass columns are the ideal choice. Its low maintenance offsets the higher upfront expense, making it an excellent option for those who value durability, aesthetics, strength, and cost-effectiveness.

Our experts recommend opting for concrete columns if carrying heavy loads is your main concern. For porches where heavy loads are pushing down from the roof or upper floors, concrete is a great material due to its strength and longevity.

If you need high capacity in a small area, steel may be the best option because of its strength-to-weight ratio. It’s worth mentioning that if your house has a modern style, this material complements the design perfectly, enhancing its appearance.

Lastly, wood posts are considered best for homeowners who prioritize customizability and low costs, and are willing to commit to regular inspections and maintenance. It’s also the perfect choice for traditional homes and can match their style very well.

Discover the Best Type of Porch Columns For Your Home Today

In this blog, we discussed the critical role that porch column material plays in structural integrity and aesthetics. We also introduced four primary materials commonly used, which you can consider for your project. After that, we provided six practical tips to help you choose the best type of porch columns for your specific situation, and also mentioned the best situations for each material.

However, you may still feel uncertain about the right choice, and that’s normal. At Roll the Wall, we are ready to help you find the best solution with a detailed inspection of your home and a comprehensive consultation. Contact us now and schedule an appointment to select the best material that suits your needs.

FAQ